Long Island Pumpkin Beer – 53 for ’21!

by Editor
Share This!

Here’s a list of the Long Island Pumpkin Beer and Autumnal offerings at local spots for fall 2021. Pumpkin beer is likely the most debated, most polarizing of any of the beers out there.

RELATED: Complete List of Long Island Breweries

Good or bad? Sugar rim or not? Is it out too soon or not soon enough!

The debates heat up every year around this time and there seems to be no end in sight. Personally, I love a good Long Island pumpkin beer with a sugar and cinnamon rim. But I’d like to wait until the end of September/beginning of October to start enjoying it. I love the seasonality of the thing and I love that it is one of the things that symbolize fall to me, like back to school and apple picking!! What a great way to ring in the fall!

RELATED: All the spots to go apple picking Long Island!

This is as comprehensive a list as I could come up with. There’s 53 beers here!!! If I am missing one, please let me know!

Long Island Pumpkin Beer & Autumnal Offerings for the 2021 Season

Nassau County, Long Island Pumpkin Beer

Let’s see what type of goodies are to be found on the western end of The Island!

Pumpkin Picker by Garvies Point Craft Brewery

A Saison packed with plenty of Pumpkin and just the right amount of spices. Seasonal aromas of Fall are accentuated by the Saison yeast. A perfect compliment to a crisp autumn day! 6.0% ABV.

1 Garvies Point Road, Glen Cove, L.I., NY 11542

Find out more by calling 516-277-02787 or by visiting garviespointbrewing.com & untappd.com

Long Island pumpkin beer
Source: oysterbaybrewing.com

Pumpkin Ale by Oyster Bay Brewing Company

Oyster Bay Pumpkin Ale is a classic bronze-colored, malt-forward, spiced beer that’s a perfect way to transition from summer to fall! 5.0% ABV

36 Audrey Avenue, Oyster Bay, L.I., NY 11771

Find out more by calling 516-802-5546 or by visiting oysterbaybrewing.com/products/pumpkin-ale

Thank Gourd Pumpkin Ale by Barnshed Brewing

100 Lauman Lane, Hicksville, L.I, NY 11801

Find out more by visiting barnshedbrewing.com

Is It Really Autunmal by Lithology Brewing Company

211A Main St., Farmingdale, L.I., NY 11735

Find out more by calling 516-962-0585 or by visiting lithologybrewing.com

Long Island pumpkin beer
Source: instagram.com/barrierbrewingco/

4 pumpkin and Oktoberfest beers by Barrier Brewing Co. (Oceanside)

This Milkshake IPA is brewed with pumpkin, vanilla, coconut, allspice, cinnamon, nutmeg, coriander, and lactose. Fall time fresh! 7.0% ABV

Schwarzbier aka Black Lager is the first up in their “Ze German” series, comes an easy drinking beauty with loads of flavor. Expect notes of bitter chocolate, mild coffee and a slight toasty finish. A clean, crisp brew with just the slightest sweetness. 5.3% ABV

Märs Zen Oktoberfest Lager. is their first OG traditional Oktoberfest beer… A biscuity and toasty malt profile, beautifully balanced by German noble hops.. This historical brew is fermented & conditioned cold with our house German lager Yeast. 6.5% ABV

Hefeweizen is the The Original Hazy Boi of the craft beer world! This cloudy straw-amber liquid broke all the rules when it came into existence waaaaaay back when… In fact, according to the German Purity laws this beer was against the rules… ahhh who doesn’t love an old fashioned outlaw! Bursting with notes of bubblegum, banana and clove… this Barrier take on an old world classic will surely hit you with all the vibes of fall!!! 5.3% ABV

3001 New Street, Oceanside, L.I., NY 11572

Find out more by calling 516-594-1028 and by visiting barrierbrewing.com

Pumpkin Spice by BrewSA (Freeport)

Deep copper appearance. Mashed with rich, toasty, Munich malt as well as a mix of pumpkin purée and spices. Malty and bold with a familiar nose of fall. 6.0% ABV

180 Woodcleft Ave, Freeport, L.I, NY 11520

Find out more by visiting brewsa.com

Your Wish Is Granted by Motion Craft Brewed

Pumpkin spiced mocha white stout. This has layers and layers of fall flavor. 8.5% ABV

1036B Park Blvd Massapequa Park, L.I., NY 11762

Find out more by calling 516-654-9555 or by visiting motioncraftbrewed.com

Pumpkin Time by South Shore Craft Brewery

This Imperial Pumpkin is made with real pumpkin, fresh ginger, spices, and molasses. 8% ABV

3505 Hampton Rd, Oceanside, L.I., NY 11572

Find out more by calling 516- 388-6685  or by visiting southshorecraftbrewery.com

Suffolk County, Long Island Pumpkin Beer

Let’s see what type of goodies are to be found in the middle and East End of The Island. As you can see, there are some brewery hubs in Suffolk, so I’ve broken those out, too, so that you can check out a few spots in the same area at one time. The easier the drinking the better, that’s what I always say.

Long Island pumpkin ale
Source: instagram.com/harborheadbrew/

Headless Helmsman by Harbor Head Brewing Company

7.5% ABV

81 Fort Salonga Road, Northport, L.I., NY

Find out more by calling 631-815-5588 or by visiting harborheadbrew.com

Pumpkin Ale by Old Tappan Brew Company 

37 Ludlam Ave, Bayville, L.I., NY 11709

Find out more by calling 516-802-0174 or by visiting oldtappanbrewingcompany.com

Pumpkin’ Out by Po’ Boy Brewery

A malt-forward ale with caramel, molasses, nutmeg, and cinnamon notes. Finishes with a moderately dry, spiced flavor. 6.5% ABV

200 Wilson St. Bldg E3 Port Jefferson Station, L.I, NY 11776

Find out more by calling 631-828-1131 or by visiting poboybrewery.com

Boo Brew by Port Jefferson Brewing Company

Fresh Hop Ale brewed with local, Long Island pumpkins, and pumpkin pie spice. 5.4% ABV

22 Mill Creek Rd, Port Jefferson, L.I., NY 11777

Find out more by calling 631-331-2959 or by visiting portjeffbrewing.com


Effin Pumpkin by 1940’s Brewing Company

A pumpkin Saison brewed with organic pumpkin puree.

1337 Lincoln Ave, Holbrook, L.I., NY 11741 

Find out more by calling 631-533-4838 and 631-256-5626  to order or by visiting 1940sbrewingcompany.com

All Hallows Eve by Spider Bite Beer Company

9% ABV

920 Lincoln Ave #5, Holbrook, L.I., NY 11741

Find out more by calling 631-942-3255 or by visiting spiderbitebeer.com

pumpkin beer with sugar rim
Source: instagram.com/harborheadbrew/

Hundred Yards Over The Rim by SquareHead Brewing

Spiced Pumpkin Ale made with Sugar Pumpkins. 5.9% ABV

420 High St., Holbrook, L.I., NY 11741

Find out more by calling 631-921-3060 or by visiting squareheadbrewing.com

Bay Shore and Islip

Like Loving The Dead by The Brewer’s Collective

This pumpkin ale is infused with coldbrew coffee. Caramel cinnamon sugar rims optional!

1460 North Clinton Avenue Bay Shore, L.I., NY 11706

Find out more by calling 631-665-9000 or by visiting facebook.com/TheBrewersCollective

Mandatory Pumpkin by Destination Unknown (DUBCO) Beer Company

5.2% ABV

1 S Chicago Ave, Bay Shore, L.I., NY 11706

Find out more by visiing destinationunknownbeercompany.com

Splashing Pumpkin by Great South Bay Brewery

This trick of a treat of Pumpkin Ale begins with roasted pumpkins that our brewers splash into our monster mash with our finest malted barley. Handfuls of cascade hops are stirred into our boiling cauldron with just a pinch of cinnamon and clove. This well balanced, tasty pumpkin brew will enlighten your soul throughout halloween and the changing autumn season. 

25 Drexel Dr, Bay Shore, L.I., NY 11706

Find out more by calling 631-392-8472 or by visiting greatsouthbaybrewery.com

Mommy Loves You, Pumpkin by Secatogue Brewing Company

Pumpkin Ale with Pumpkin, Vanilla, Maple Syrup and Pumpkin Spice. 6% ABV

375 Union Boulevard, West Islip, L.I., NY 11795

Find out more by calling 631-228-8914 or by visiting secatoguebrewing.com

Riverhead and North Fork

Incarnation Pumpkin Spice by Tradewinds Brewing Company 

5.2% ABV

70 W Main St, Riverhead, L.I., NY 11901

Find out more by visiting tradewindsbrewing.com

Pumpkin Ale at Garden of Eve Farm Brewery 

4558 Sound Avenue, Riverhead, L.I., NY 11901

Find out more by calling or by 631-722-8777 visiting gardenofevefarm.com

Source: greenportharborbrewing.com

2 beers by Greenport Harbor Brewing Company

Leaf Pile Ale pours a copper color with a nose full of warm malts and fall spices. Brewed with a blend of light and medium crystal malts and just a touch of hops to provide a foundation for fresh crushed cinnamon, allspice, and ginger autumn goodness. 5.2% ABV

Festbier is brewed to celebrate fall on the North Fork. Toasty and pleasantly malty but not sweet, with just enough balancing hop bitterness, will keep you coming back for another Maß stein. 5.4% ABV

Peconic Tasting Room & Restaurant – 42155 Main Road, Peconic NY

Greenport Tasting Room – 234 Carpenter Street, Greenport NY

Find out more by calling Peconic at 631-477-1100 or by visiting greenportharborbrewing.com

Sugar Skull Pumpkin at Jamesport Farm Brewery

Not your typical pumpkin ale. Not too sweet, not too spicy, not too squashy. A well balanced seasonal brew. 4.7% ABV

5873 Sound Avenue, Riverhead, L.I., NY 11901

Find out more by calling 844-JFB-BEER (844-532-2337) or by visiting jfbrewery.com

Pumpkin Ale by Long Ireland Beer Company

Real pumpkin and a blend of spices lend  Fall flavors and aromas balanced by caramel and smokey malts to this seasonal craft beer favorite. 5.25 ABV

817 Pulaski St, Riverhead, L.I., NY 11901

Find out more by calling 631-403-4303 or by visiting longirelandbeer.com

Start to Fall by Moustache Brewing Company

A rich, subtly sweet, toasty märzen.

Tasting room is closed, but you can find their beer at: google.com/maps

Find out more by visiting moustachebrewing.com

Burning Down the Fest by North Fork Brewing Company

This Märzen-inspired beer is everything we love about our favorite Fall German lagers. Using subtle smoked malts, and crystal malts, this is our ode and interpretation to the sacred style.

24 E 2nd St. Ste A, Riverhead, L.I., NY 11901

Find out more by calling 631-591-1191 or by visiting northforkbrewingco.com

Harvest Notes Ale by Twin Fork Brewery

Fall seasonal spiced ale flavored with hints of cinnamon, ginger, and nutmeg. 4.9% ABV

807 Raynor Ave, Riverhead, L.I., NY 11901

Find out more by calling 631-209-4233 or by visiting twinforkbeer.com

Long Island oktoberfest beer
Source: instagram.com/ubergeekbrewing

3 differents ales by übergeek Brewing Company

i don’t wanna force it is a pumpkin ale. a parsec is a unit of length, not time is a pumpkin ale w/ Banana. that’s what black holes are for is a tart pumpkin w/ Tart Cherries and Vanilla.

400 Hallett Avenue, Riverhead, L.I., NY

Find out more by visiting ubergeekbrewing.com

Camp Hero Haunted Pumpkin Ale by Peconic County Brewing

Medium bodied ale with hints of cinnamon nutmegand allspice. 6.2% ABV

221 East Main Street, Riverhead, L.I., NY 11901

Find out more by calling 631-740-9797 or by visiting peconiccountybrewing.com

Patchogue and South Shore

2 lagers by 27A Brewing Company

Fall Lager is a crisp lager. 5.5% ABV. Pumpkin Pie Lager is a crisp lager finished with a proprietary blend of pumpkin puree and spice. 5.5% ABV

173 North Wellwood Ave, Lindenhurst, L.I., NY 11757

Find out more by visiting 27abrewing.com

Pumpkin Pie Ale by Bellport Brewing

Not only does this pumpkin ale come with a cinammon and sugar rim, it also comes with whipped cream, too!

14 Station Rd, Bellport, L.I., NY 11713

Find out more by visiting bellportbrewing.com

Blue Point Mother Pumpkin
Source: bluepointbrewing.com

2 beers by Blue Point Brewing Company

Mother Pumpkin Ale is a golden orange-colored Pumpkin Ale boasts all the flavors of fall: cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger, and allspice. These spicy characteristics take the lead in this roasty beer while the malty backbone adds to the tremendous depth of character. Pair all these complex flavors with all the pumpkin-spiced/apple crisp flavors found in the dishes of the season! 5.5 ABV

Oktoberfest, originally brewed a couple hundred years ago to celebrate the betrothal of the Crown Prince of Bavaria, we’re helping keep the tradition alive by brewing Oktoberfest every fall for our most royal/loyal followers. Blue Point Oktoberfest is a rare example of the traditional German Oktoberfest style, particularly on the East coast where autumn seasonals are more common.

225 W Main St., Patchogue, L.I., NY 11772

Find out more by calling 631-627-8292 or by visiting bluepointbrewing.com

2 beers from BrickHouse Brewery

Oktoberfest Märzen, a malty, traditional fall lager. 5.4% ABV and Keegan Ales (brewed by BrickHouse founders) Pumpkin Pie Farmhouse Ale.

67 W Main Street, Patchogue, L.I., NY 11772

Find out more by calling 631-447-2337 or by visiting brickhousebrewery.com

2 biers by Darling Brewing Co. 

Festbier is sold out and Pumpkin Altbier is coming soon.

76 West Main Street, Patchogue, L.I., NY 11772

Find out more by calling 631-307-9676 or by visiting darlingbrewingco.com

Graveyeard Smash by Sand City Brewing Company

Ale brewed with pumpkin and spices. 7.2% ABV

Sand City North

60 Main St., Northport, L.I., NY, 11768


Sand City South

150 S. Wellwood Ave, Lindenhurst, L.I., NY 11757

Find out more by visiting sandcitybeer.com and untappd.com

Six Harbors Brewing Company

Past versions have included Pumpkin Session IPA and Pumpkin Dark.

243 New York Ave, Huntington, L.I., NY 11743

Find out more by calling 631-470-1560 or by visiting sixharborsbrewingcompany.com

2 meads by WA Meadwerks

Is it really autumnal is a pumpkin spiced mead with Cinnamon, Nutmeg, Ginger, and Allspice. 6.7% ABV. Basic Bee Caramel Candy Apple is a new mead modeled after one of your favorite fall treats! 6.8% ABV

26 West Hoffman Ave, Lindenhurst, L.I., NY 11757

Find out more by calling 516-607-5664 or by visiting wameadwerks.com

Other Eastern Long Island Breweries

pumpkin ale with cinnamon and sugar rim
Source: longislandfarmbrewery.com

Pickin’ Pumpkins by Long Island Farm Brewery

Brewed with Pumpkin, cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg and vanilla. 5.5% ABV

663 Wading River Road, Manorville, L.I., NY 11949

Find out more by calling 631-909-1864 or by visiting longislandfarmbrewery.com

RELATED: Tulip Festival at Waterdrinker Farm

RELATED: Sunflower Festival Near Me: Waterdrinker in Manorville

Pumpkin Ave by Montauk Brewing Company

Fall is a beautiful time in Montauk. The leaves change color, the air cools off, the traffic thins, and the beaches clear out. Montauk Pumpkin Ale is a sign of the season – just the right amount of spices along with subtle hop aromas, this beer highlights the time of year just perfectly. 5.7% ABV

62 S Erie Ave, Montauk, L.I., NY 11954

Find out more by calling 631-668-8471 or by visiting montaukbrewingco.com

2 beers by Moriches Field Brewing Company

Moriches Field Oktoberfest marzen is a rich amber lager that hints at malty sweetness but it has a surprising light finish for such a rich beer. This beer style was originally brewed to be consumed in large quantities at German beer halls during Oktoberfest. Today, it’s a staple in America during the Oktoberfest season. Ein Prosit! 6.1% ABV

Festive Trickster Festbier is a traditional golden festbier brewed as an ale with the LOKI strain of Norwegian Kviek. It goes down easy, unlike the setting sun. 6.0% ABV

1 Wilcox Avenue, Center Moriches, L.I., NY 11934

Find out more by calling 631-909-4404 or by visiting morichesfieldbrewing.com

Hampton Pumpkin by Westhampton Beach Brewing Company

Fall in love with the Hampton Pumpkin! This medium bodied amber ale is infused with nutmeg, cinnamon, ginger and all the other delicious flavors of the season. It is served with a cinnamon sugar rim to help bring all the spices together enhancing the experience of this season’s favorite brew.  The Hampton Pumpkin is the perfect complement to a long Sunday of watching football or the tasty reward for a hard day of raking leaves. For a cool evening by your favorite fireplace or fire pit, take home the Hampton Pumpkin Ale. 

220 Roger’s Way, Suite I, Westhampton Beach, L.I., NY 11978

Find out more by calling 631-998-0800 or by visiting westhamptonbeachbrewingco.com

Long Island Brewery Tours

If you’re like me, part of the fun is seeing all the different spaces and experiencing all that craft beer Long Island has to offer. Perhaps one of the easiest and best ways to do this is to take a brewery tour!

Check out my list of the Absolute Best Long Island Brewery Tours!

I love going to breweries, it’s something I do a fair amount with my friends. While I haven’t been to nearly all of these, I do know that whether the beer is the best or the place is the nicest…or vice versa, it always ends up being a great time. Plus, you get to support some passionate people putting their hearts and souls into their craft. And it’s local. That’s always something to celebrate.

More About the Beer

If you can’t make it out for a tour, be sure to look into beer delivery!

Check Out What’s New In Long Island Brewing for 2020 and 2021!!!

Read more about some of the best Long Island craft beer around!

More From The Long Island Local

Maybe grab a freshly brewed beer at these Long Island breweries!

And how about all the wonderful Wölffer Estate Vineyard events and tastings?! Or maybe check out some Long Island oyster farms! How about these guides to Long Island Coffee Shops and Long Island coffee roasters!! Check out these 16 Long Island Boardwalks! Take the ferry over and enjoy these Fire Island restaurants! Let’s not forget about the best tacos on Long Island and these 32 great Long Island pizza places either!! Here are 21 great spots to enjoy Long Island Gelato!

Be sure to find out about more things to do on Long Island as well as more great spots to eat and drink! Maybe take a stroll in one of these amazing Long Island arboretums and gardens! There are even this great Long Island kayaks and paddleboard guide to exploring!

Long Island Farm Guides To Explore

Suffolk County agriculture includes over 560 farms with 4,600 people that generate more than $226 million in sales annually. Long Island knows farming as well as Long Island farmland preservation!! How about enjoying some wonderful Long Island hiking trails!

Check out more Long Island Farm coverage on The Long Island Local!

Explore our Guide to organic farms on Long Island and our Guide to CSA on Long Island.

Read about great events like the Tulip Festival at Waterdrinker Farm and all that the Golden Earthworm has to offer!

What about this massive list of Long Island farmers and farms you need to visit!

How about Long Island Oyster Farms, the last Long Island Duck farm, or the only fresh American snail farm Peconic Escargot!

When the season’s right, explore our Long Island Christmas Tree farm guide and our list of great Long Island pumpkin picking farms!

Check Out Long Island Wine

If you’re in the mood for great wine, be sure to check out our Complete List of Long Island Wineries and Long Island Vineyards.

Check out the absolute best Long Island Wine Tours!

If you can’t make it to a tour, why not do some wine tasting at home with Bedell Cellars!

I know you’re getting hungry, so be sure to also check out the best wineries on Long Island for some great food!

While you’re in the area, be sure to check out these 9 relaxing things to do in the North Fork!

When you’re done with all of this wine drinking and relaxing, how about making it a weekend? Here are 10 great North Fork Long Island hotels to enjoy as well.

Things To See and Do on the South Fork

I always recommend seeing as much of the South Fork as possible!! 

The Hamptons and Montauk is a world-renowned beach resort destination for good reason! There is just so much to see, do, and enjoy! Here are just a few of them:

Check out this Guide to the Best Beaches in Montauk! Also, check out this Guide to The Hamptons best beaches!!

Check out some luxury homes in The Hamptons!

Maybe you will love it so much, you’ll want to check out some Hamptons wedding venues!

Enjoy some of the world-class, amazing art in The Hamptons!

While You’re Enjoying the Outdoors

Be sure to find out about more things to do on Long Island as well as more great spots to eat and drink and wonderful places to stay on Long Island!

Check out this guide to Long Island driving ranges, including this feature on the popular Heartland driving range! Go have fun at one of these great Long Island skate parks!

Make It A Weekend

The East End of Long Island is a really special spot. If you think you’d want to check it out and maybe even stay a while…that wouldn’t be such a terrible idea.

If you wanted to consider different options for staying on Long Island, be sure to check out these great places to stay in Montauk, 11 Hamptons hotels, 10 North Fork Long Island hotels, and this Guide to Sag Harbor hotels! Enjoy reading up on and hopefully exploring these wonderful Shelter Island hotels and let me know if you decide to make it a vacation!

Share This!

Related Articles

Leave a Comment

This website uses third party applications that may use cookies to improve your experience. You can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More

Privacy & Cookies Policy