Ultimate Long Island Pumpkin Picking List: 38 Spots

by Editor
Share This!

For those looking for the best Long Island pumpkin picking farms, you will have a hard time choosing. They are all great! Fall aficionados aren’t we all looking for an awesome pumpkin patch, Long Island! Well, you’re in luck, as there are several of them that are so much more than just pumpkins. It’s time to enjoy the autumn air, take in some country vibes, and get pumpkin picking Long Island!

NOTE: This has been updated for 2021 and will be continuously updated as the season progresses.

long island pumpkin picking
Source: Fink’s Country Farm

Long Island Pumpkin Picking Season

The season for pumpkins typically begins in September and runs to Halloween (or the weekend afterward). Each farm is a bit different though so be sure to check out availability, cost, and hours before heading out. Take a minute to go to the farm’s website for guidance on social distancing, masks, and other precautions if there are any still in effect.

RELATED: All the spots to go apple picking Long Island!

More Than Just Pumpkin Picking

If you decide to head to the pumpkin farms, Long Island has options that are fun for the whole family. This is one of those outdoor Fall traditions kids of all ages, yes, even teenagers, can get into. Many of the best pumpkin picking Long Island farms offer fun, seasonal activities. There’s more to do than just pick out your perfect carving specimen. Be sure to warm up with some apple cider or snack on the delicious homemade goodies for sale at many of the farm’s markets. 

Want to pick apples too? Of course, you do! You’re in luck, as it is now apple picking season too! And there are apple and pumpkin picking Long Island farms throughout the East End. You can combine some of your favorites and pick a pumpkin and some Red Delicious goodies. Are you ready to see the list and get pumpkin picking Long Island??

RELATED: Guide to Halloween on Long Island

RELATED: Long Island Pumpkin Beer – 53 for ’21!

pumpkin picking long island
Source: Hank’s Pumpkintown

38 Pumpkin Picking Long Island Farms

Albert H. Schmitt Family Farms

If ever there were a place for family fun, Albert H. Schmitt Family Farms is that place. This farm offers fun for the entire family with you-pick pumpkins, hayrides, animal train rides, trikes, and a games area. You’ll also find fall décor, plants, cornstalks, mums, ornamental kale and cabbage, and a host of other fall favorites. All the while, you’ll enjoy roasted corn, pies, candy apples, apples, and hot cider. Don’t forget to bring home some of their famous Holy Schmitt’s horseradish!

Open 7 days a week. Thursday-Sunday: 10 AM – 6 PM and Monday-Wednesday: 10 AM – 5 PM

6 Bagatelle Rd, Dix Hills, L.I. NY 11746

Find out more by calling 631-549-3276 or visiting schmittsfamilyfarms.com/

Andrews Family Farm and Greenhouses

Find the perfect pumpkin for your family at Andrews Family Farm and Greenhouses. In addition to classic pumpkin picking, this farm boasts specialty gourds, straw bales, corn stalks, and fall plants such as mums and Montauk daisies. You’ll also find fresh veggies and tasty treats like classic pies, and on the weekends, you’ll want to try their roasted corn. 

Hours: 9 AM – 5 PM daily through late October. 

1038 Sound Ave. Wading River, L.I., NY 11933

Find out more by calling 631-929-0038 or visiting andrewsfamilyfarm.com/

Atlantic Nursery & Garden Shop

Fall fun is waiting at Atlantic Nursery. Here, you’ll find farm animals and a petting zoo, a hay maze, a mini corn maze, a tire crawl, and the haunted hideaway. You’ll also enjoy activities like the tire crawl, build your own scarecrow, children’s scavenger hunt, and pumpkin and face painting. While you’re there, don’t forget to check out their fall harvest and decorative market bursting with seasonal plants. 

Hours: 9 AM – 5 PM daily. 

250 Atlantic Ave. Freeport, L.I., NY 11520

Find out more by calling 516-378-7357 or visiting atlanticnursery.com/

BB & GG Farm & Nursery

Visit BB & GG Farm for one of the largest selections of vegetables, fall plants, pumpkins, gourds, and more that you’ll ever find. In addition to their massive plant selection, you’ll find pumpkin-picking, a corn maze, hayrides, and that fall favorite, roasted corn. 

Hours: 8 AM – 6 PM every day. Closed Thanksgiving Day

625 N. Country Rd. St. James, L.I., NY 11780

Find out more by calling 631-862-9182 or visiting facebook.com/BB-GG-Farm-333574123367234/

Benner’s Farm

Benner’s Farm offers a lot more than just Long Island pumpkin picking. It’s open on weekends year-round, offering families the chance to see this working farm and even newborn animals in spring. During the fall, this place shines.

In addition to pumpkin-picking, you’ll find a one-day Harvest Festival in October that features live music and cider-making, and when Halloween approaches, the family can enjoy a haunted hayride. There’s a Pumpkin Field, Music, Apples, ‘the BIG swing’, Animals, and more.

Harvest Weekend is October 9th and 10th in 2021

Hours: Every weekend, year-round. 

56 Gnarled Hollow Rd. East Setauket, L.I., NY 11733

Find out more by calling 631-689-8172 or visiting bennersfarm.com/

Borella’s Farm Stand 

Borella’s Farm Stand has something for every fall lover out there. At the farm stand, you’ll find mums, flowering kale, and a host of other beautiful flowering plants along with fresh vegetables; Autumn décor; corn stalks; hay bales; and fun Halloween lawn art.

Hours: 10 AM – 5 PM every day through Halloween.

They also host a Fall Festival complete with you-pick pumpkins, hayrides, roasted corn, a corn maze, live music, and inflatable bounce houses for the kids. They’re also open on Columbus Day, but an entry fee is required. 

$12.00 per person includes: Unlimited Hay Rides to and from our on-the-vine pumpkin patch, Corn Maze, Entertainment for young children (Conk the Crow, Milk the Cow, Duck Races, Witch Hat Toss), and the new Pumpkin Bounce Pad 

Fall festival hours: 11 AM – 5 PM weekends in October.

485 Edgewood Ave. St. James, L.I., NY 11780

Find out more by calling 631-862-7330 or visiting borellasfarmstand.com/

Brightwaters Farms 

Enjoy everything you love about fall at Brightwaters with you-pick pumpkins, hayrides, and a Fall Harvest Festival filled with entertainment, snacks, activities, and fun. Don’t forget to check out their variety of fall plants, as well. 

Families will love searching the cozy 3-acre field at Brightwater Farms for their perfect pumpkin. Call ahead for hours as they may change. In addition to the pumpkin picking, you’ll find activities like bean bag toss, petting farm, hayrides, a playground, and more family fun. These activities are available on weekends and Columbus Day.

Hours: 9 AM – 5 PM daily through October 31st

1624 Manatuck Blvd., Bay Shore-Brightwaters, L.I., NY 11706

Find out more by calling 631-665-5411 or visiting brightwatersfarms.com/

Crossroads Farm at Grossmann’s

Stop by Crossroads Farm for some of the best pumpkin picking Long Island has to offer. In addition to beautiful pumpkins,, at their farm stand, you’ll find top-quality, organic produce along with seedlings and handmade soaps. It’s the closest organic farm to New York City, preserved by the non-profit Nassau Land Trust!

Farm Stand Hours: Friday 3 PM – 6 PM, Saturday 9 AM – 3 PM, and Sunday 9 AM – 3 PM

​Farmer’s Market Every Saturday, 9 AM – 1 PM

480 Hempstead Ave. Malverne, L.I., NY 11565

Find out more by calling 516-881-7900 or visiting xroadsfarmliny.com/

Elwood Pumpkin and Christmas Tree Farm 

Elwood offers you-pick pumpkins in white and orange, along with a variety of gourds and ornamental fall plants to help you get your home fall-ready and have the best Jack-O-Lanterns in the neighborhood. They also offer a corn maze, kid-friendly maze, and a 10-minute educational hayride around the farm. 

Weekend Hours Starting on 9/25/2021: 10 AM -5 PM, Weekday Hours (Monday-Friday) Starting on 10/1/2021-10/31/2021: 3 PM – 5 PM

1500 E. Jericho Tpke. Huntington, L.I., NY 11743

Find out more by calling 631-368-8626 or visiting elwoodpumpkinfarm.com/

F&W Schmitt Farms

In addition to you-pick pumpkins, you’ll also be able to pick your own vegetables at F&W. When the Halloween season rolls around, they also feature a haunted corn trail and haunted mansion.

Their Fall Festival is held every weekend through October 31st and Columbus day and features a 7-acre corn maze, a petting zoo, a playground, a wagon ride, and treats like roasted corn, candy apples, pies, and hard cider. 

Admission $10/Person includes Hayride, Playground, Mini Golf, and Photo Ops.

Additional (not included in the $10 admission) Offerings: Pumpkin Picking, Sunflower Picking, Vegetable Picking, Pony Rides, Petting Zoo, Concessions, Farm Stand, Roasted Corn, Pumpkin Wagons, Daytime Corn Maze, Haunted House, Haunted Corn Trail

Hours: 12 PM – 5 PM daily through October 31st

Fall Festival Hours: 10 AM – 5 PM weekends through October 31st and Columbus Day. 

26 Pinelawn Rd, Melville, L.I., NY 11747

Find out more by calling 631-271-3276 or visiting schmittfarms.com/

Fairview Farm 

In addition to you-pick pumpkins, Fairview Farm offers all the produce you’d expect from a farm stand. You’ll find all manner of fall vegetables, along with pies, roasted corn, popcorn, ribbon fries, pumpkin donuts, and cider. You’ll also want to try making your way through their massive, 8-acre corn maze. 

Hours: 10 AM – 6 PM Friday – Sunday. 

19 Horsemill Ln. Bridgehampton, L.I., NY 11932

Find out more by calling 631-537-6154 or visiting fairviewfarmatmecox.com/

Fink’s Country Farm

Find the perfect pumpkin at Fink’s you-pick pumpkin patch, but don’t forget to take advantage of everything else while you’re there. Fink’s offers a Spookie Flashlight Maze, a playground, a concession stand, and a farm stand offering roasted corn, hot cider, cornstalks, mums, produce, straw bales, and holiday decorations. They also have a Fall Festival every weekend and on Columbus Day boasting a corn maze, hayrides, an animal farm, live music from noon to 4 PM, and pony rides.

Farm Stand Hours: 9 AM – 5 PM daily through December 23rd
Fall Festival Hours: 9:30 AM – 5 PM Columbus Day and weekends through November 1st

6242 Middle Country Rd. Wading River, L.I., NY 11792

Find out more by calling 631-886-2272 or visiting finksfarm.com/

Gabrielsen’s Country Farm

Gabrielsen’s offers you-pick pumpkins, along with a variety of fall plants like mums, Montauk daisies, ornamental cabbage, and ornamental kale. You’ll also find tasty fall treats like roasted corn and candy apples. While you’re there picking pumpkins and snacking, take advantage of their Fall Festival running through October 31st. It features A train, hayrides, a corn crib, kiddie maze, farm animals, pedal tractors, and live music on the weekends. 

Open 7 days a week (including holidays) from 8 AM – 6 PM from Mid-March thru December 24th.

200 Herricks Ln. Jamesport, L.I., NY 11947

Find out more by calling 631-722-3259 or visiting gabrielsenscountryfarm.com/

Garden of Eve 

Garden of Eve offers everything you love about pumpkin patches plus a little something extra. In addition to you-pick pumpkins from the vine, hayrides, a picnic area, farm animals, a snack bar, and a farm stand overflowing with fall veggies, mums, cornstalks, and fall decorations, you also be able to enjoy great beers from their on-site craft brewery. 

Open Daily 9 AM – 6 PM from April 1 – Halloween.

4558 Sound Ave. Riverhead, L.I., NY 11901

Find out more by calling 631-722-8777 or visiting gardenofevefarm.com/

Glover Farms 

Take the family for a day of pumpkin picking, kids’ activities, hayrides, and more at Glover Farms. The farm also features a picnic area, corn maze, farm animals, a snack bar, and a farm stand with fresh vegetables, mums, cornstalks, and various fall decorations. 

Hours: Weekdays from 2:00 PM – 6:00 PM and Weekends from 10:00 AM – 6:00 PM through October 31st and Columbus day. 

633 Victory Ave. Brookhaven, L.I., NY 11719

Find out more by calling 631-286-7876 or 631-332-2012 or visiting facebook.com/GloverFarmsBrookhaven/

Greenland Family Farms

THIS FARM HAS BEEN SOLD TO SANG LEE FARMS. Check with the farm beforehand to see what is being offered.

Hours: 9 AM – 5 PM Wednesday – Monday.

17155 Middle Rd. Cutchogue, L.I., NY 11935

Find out more by calling 631-734-5791 or visiting greenlandfamilyfarms.com/

Hank’s Pumpkintown

This enormous farm has crops spanning over 420 acres, with 48 acres devoted solely to pumpkins. This is the place to find the perfect pumpkin from small, decorative pumpkins to massive whoppers.

In addition to picking your prize pumpkin, you can also snag some apples, take a spin through their corn maze, hop on a tractor, and have 16 acres of family fun! (Note that the extra activities are open only on the weekends.). Enjoy a playground, a corn maze, narrated hayrides, family corn trains, jump pads, duck races, slides, pedal cart racing, calf milking, pic races, a treasure hunt maze, and Hank’s corn head.

Don’t forget to stop by the market to take home homemade pies, freshly roasted corn, candy apples, and other tasty treats. Hank’s PumpkinTown sells pumpkins of all shapes and sizes that are grown on-site. They also sell all the Fall-themed decorations you may be looking for including gourds, straw bales, Indian corn, Montauk Daisies, and more.

Hours: 9:30 AM – 6 PM daily beginning September 12th

240 Montauk Hwy., Water Mill, L.I., NY 11976

Find out more by calling 631-726-4667 or visiting hankspumpkintown.com/

Harbes Family Farm and Vineyard

Harbes Family Farm and Vineyard has a little bit of everything when it comes to fall fun. Come for the you-pick pumpkins but stay for hayride and corn maze, farm stand with a variety of vegetables, gourds, and mums, the wine tasting barn, and their Fall Festival. 

Come to one of the three locations of the Harbes Family Farm in Riverhead, Jamesport, and Mattituck. There are acres of family fun at each farm. You can pick pumpkins of course as well as apples (as long as they are available). They also have a corn maze, pony rides, and more kid-centered activities. This farm is open daily weather permitting so call ahead or check out their website before making the drive. The Harbes Farms locations offer some of the best pumpkin picking Long Island has to offer. The on-the-vine pumpkin picking makes Harbes stand out on the North Fork of Long Island. Note that at the Riverhead location, you must purchase an apple picking package to also pick pumpkins.

Hours: Farmstand open Daily 10 AM – 6 PM, Barnyard Adventure open Daily 10 AM – 6 PM, and Wine Barn open Daily 11 AM – 6 PM

715 Sound Ave., Mattituck, L.I., NY 11952

Find out more by calling the farm at 631-298-0800, the wine tasting bar at 631-298-9463, or visiting harbesfamilyfarm.com/

pumpkin patch long island
Source: Harbes Farm Jamesport

Harbes Farm in Jamesport

Part of the Harbes Farms family, Harbes Farm in Jamesport offers you-pick pumpkins, hayrides, a corn maze, live music, all sorts of kids’ activities, and wine tasting. That’s just to start. They also have a great, seasonal Fall Festival. 

Hours: 9 AM – 6 PM weekends and Columbus Day through November 1st.

1223 Rt. 25, Jamesport, L.I., NY 11947

Find out more by calling 631-722-2022 or visiting harbesfamilyfarm.com/

Harbes Orchard

The final of the three Harbes farms, Harbes Orchard features some of the best apple and pumpkin picking Long Island has to offer. Enjoy you-pick pumpkins, a Spooky corn maze, a Robin Hood corn maze, a café, wine tasting, and a wide selection of mums and gourds. 

Hours: Monday & Friday 10 AM-5 PM, Saturday, Sunday & Holidays 9 AM-6 PM, Closed Tuesday-Thursday.
Spooky Corn Maze Hours: 7 PM – 9:30 PM Saturday nights through October. 

5698 Sound Ave., Riverhead, L.I., NY 11901

Find out more by calling 631-369-1111 or 631-298-0800 or visiting harbesorchard.com/

Hicks Nurseries

Before heading out to their large pumpkin patch to find your perfect pumpkin, take the kids to see Otto the Ghost, the Hicks mascot. In addition to searching for the best pumpkin ever, the family will enjoy hayrides, pictures with Otto the Ghost, an animated children’s story, a petting zoo, children’s workshops, and concessions. 

Hours: 8 AM – 6 PM daily. 

100 Jericho Turnpike, Westbury, L.I., NY 11590

Find out more by calling 516-334-0066 or visiting hicksnurseries.com/

Krupski’s Farm

You can pick much more than pumpkins at this 50-acre farm. Look for pumpkins along with other fresh vegetables in their 1.5-acre you-pick field. The family will also enjoy hayrides, a haunted barn, a haunted corn maze, hay bales, and a farm stand offering seasonal vegetables. Remember, the farm stand is only open on the weekends. 

Hours: 10 AM – 6 PM Monday – Thursday. 9 AM – 6 PM Friday – Sunday.

38020 Rt. 25, Peconic, L.I., NY 11958

Find out more by calling 631-734-7841 or visiting facebook.com/Krupski-Farms-103854429678626/

Lenny Bruno Farms 

In addition to you-pick pumpkins, this farm offers a 4-acre corn maze, a play area, hayrides, and even great fall photo ops. You’ll also find a farm stand with roasted corn, mums, cornstalks, hay bales, and other fall items. 

Bonus: Their pick your own generally starts early-mid August and includes bell peppers, long hots, cheese peppers, hot cherry peppers, sweet cherry peppers, fryers, white peppers, plum tomatoes, beefsteak tomatoes, black eggplant, little finger eggplant, flat beans, as well as fall pumpkins.

Hours: 9 AM – 6 PM Monday – Thursday. 9 AM – 10 PM Friday – Sunday through Thanksgiving. 

740 Wading River Rd., Manorville, L.I., NY 11949

Find out more by calling 631-591-3592 or visiting lennybrunofarms.com/

Lewin Farms

This fourth-generation farm offers the public acres and acres of you-pick produce including all your table favorites, 60 acres of you-pick pumpkins, and a wide variety of gourds. Don’t forget to stop by their farm stand for tons of fall favorites and try out their newly-designed, 5-acre corn maze. 

Come to Lewin Farms in Calverton to pick your own pumpkins, as well as a wide variety of apples, peppers, gourds, and other fruits and vegetables. You can even get your Christmas tree here later in the year. The roasted corn at the farm stand, open every day except Tuesday, is always a hit, as is the corn maze. The corn maze is spread out over 5 acres and is open on weekends and holidays through the end of October. Plan on it taking about 25-30 minutes to complete!

Hours: 9 AM – 4:30 PM daily. The farmstand is open until 5 PM.

812 Sound Ave., Calverton, L.I., NY 11933

Find out more by calling 631-929-4327 or visiting lewinfarm.com/

May’s Farm Stand

Head to May’s Farm Stand to choose the perfect pumpkin from their you-pick pumpkin patch. You’ll also find a variety of gourds along with mums and other fall plants, sweet peppers, corn, cornstalks, and straw bales at their farm stand. Don’t forget their Fall Festival held every weekend with a 2-acre corn maze, hayrides, roasted corn, pies, music, and costumes characters.

Hours: 9 AM – 6 PM daily through October. Reopens after Thanksgiving. 

6361 NY-25A, Wading River, L.I., NY 11792

Find out more by calling 631-929-6654 or visiting maysfarmny.com/

Organics Today Farm

This farm is devoted to organic growing methods and is known for its heirloom tomatoes and vegetables. Stop by during the fall to search for the perfect pumpkin in their 3-acre field. While you’re there, enjoy tractor rides, concessions, and a farm stand selling everything from hay bales and scarecrows to mums. 

Hours: 9 AM – 6 PM daily. Open Everyday From 1st day of Spring to Thanksgiving Eve.

Pumpkin picking begins September 21st. Open Saturday nights in October from 6 PM – 9 PM for moonlight pumpkin picking (not scary).

169 Washington St., East Islip, L.I., NY 11730

Find out more by calling 631-480-6497 or visiting organicstodayfarms.com/

Pat and Don’s Pumpkin Farm Stand

Apples are available from August to November at Pat and Don’s Pumpkin Farm Stand. But you may want to splurge on the apple pie — it’s known for being the best this side of Briermere Farms. 

Open daily, 9 AM to 6 PM until October 31st. 

142 Long Island Ave, Yaphank, L.I., 11980

Find out more by calling 631-924-7444 or by visiting pumpkinpatchfarmstand.com

Pantaleons Farm

This farm features a farm stand that offers some of the best fall plants and fresh vegetables to be found in Long Island. You’ll also find a you-pick pumpkin patch, a wide variety of gourds, a kids’ playground, hayrides, and more. 

Hours: 9 AM – 6 PM Monday – Saturday. 9 AM – 5 PM Sunday. 

445 NY-25A, East Setauket, L.I., NY 11733

Find out more by calling 631-608-8331 or visiting facebook.com/PantaleonsFarm/

Rottkamp’s Fox Hollow Farm

Rottkamp’s takes a slightly different approach to their seasonal fun. Of course, you’ll find you-pick pumpkins, but you’ll also find a unique maze made of sunflowers rather than corn. Be sure to visit their farm stand, which offers a variety of produce along with tasty treats. While you’re there, send the kids out to play in their play area. 

Farm Stand Hours: 9 AM – 5:30 PM daily. Closed Wednesday. Through October 31st.
Pumpkin Picking and Sunflower Maze Hours: 11: AM – 6 PM daily. Closed Wednesday. Through October 31st

2287 Sound Avenue, Baiting Hollow, L.I., NY 11933

Find out more by calling 631-727-1786 or visiting facebook.com/Rottkamps-Fox-Hollow-Farm-1681094095465096/

RELATED: Check out this Guide to Long Island Arboretums and Gardens!

Schmitt’s Farm Country Fresh

The fall harvest ends its season with pumpkins, local apples, fresh local apple cider, gourds, corn stalks, hay bales,  mums, and fall decorations.  See if you can weave your way through their mega corn maze while you’re there.

Hours: 9 AM – 6 PM daily from May to October.

1305 Main Road, Laurel, L.I., NY 11948

Find out more by calling 631-271-3276 or visiting schmittsfarmcountryfresh.com/

Seven Ponds Orchard

Seven Ponds Orchard is all about family fun when fall comes around. Head over to the orchard for you-puck pumpkins and apples. After you’ve harvested a bumper crop, enjoy a corn maze, hayride with music and narration, a cow train, duck races, pedal cars, and a variety of sunflowers and vegetables. 

Hours: 9 AM – 6 PM daily through Thanksgiving. 

65 Seven Ponds Rd., Water Mill, L.I., NY 11976

Find out more by calling 631-726-8015 or visiting facebook.com/Seven-Ponds-Orchard-160316560714096/

Source: Stakey’s Pumpkin Farm

Stakey’s Pumpkin Farm

With 26 acres of you-pick pumpkins, if you can’t find the perfect pumpkin here, you can’t find it anywhere. After finding your pumpkins, try the corn maze and enjoy hayrides, a bounce house, face painting, a country store with everything from seasonal plants to tasty goodies, and a flower house. There are so many shapes and colors of pumpkin, I literally have no idea there were so many until I came here! The theme of the 2021 corn maze is Robin Hood!

Hours: Open weekdays 12 PM – 5 PM and weekends and school holidays 9 AM – 5 PM from September 18, 2021 – October 30, 2021.

270 West Ln., Aquebogue, L.I., NY 11931

Find out more by calling 631-722-3467 or visiting stakeyspumpkinfarm.com/

The Dee’s Nursery & Florist

If you’re looking for a huge variety of family fun activities, The Dee’s is the place. In addition to their large, you-pick pumpkin patches, the family will find a petting zoo, children’s corn maze, gem mining, pumpkin painting, a spooky walkthrough, and as the name suggests, a huge variety of beautiful plants. 

Regular Store Hours (Mid-February thru June and September thru November) are Monday – Sunday 9 AM to 5 PM. Closed Thanksgiving Day, Christmas Day, New Years Day. Winter Hours (January thru Mid-February) are Wednesday – Sunday
9 AM to 5 PM, Closed Monday and Tuesday (Except Valentine’s Day Week). Summer Hours (mid-July through August) are Wednesday – Sunday 9 AM to 5 PM, Closed Monday and Tuesday. Holiday Hours (December) Monday – Saturday 8 AM – 7 PM, Sunday – 8 AM – 6 PM.

Fall Festival every Saturday and Sunday in October from 10 AM – 5 PM. On-site Pumpkin Patch, Corn Roaster weekends 12-5, Jericho Cider Mill Products, Amazing Décor & Family Picture Taking Spots. Family Entrance Fee – $10.99 includes an interactive petting zoo, food for the animals, a haunted maze, and a hay slide. Pumpkin Painting – $14.99 includes pumpkin, apron, 5 individual paints, and brushes. Decorating station has googly eyes, glitter, ribbons, and pom-poms to use!!!! Gem & Fossil Mining – $14.99 – Kids will mine paydirt or fossil finds through the mining sluice and go home with beautiful gems or amazing fossils. Pumpkin & Mining COMBO – $24.99 (SAVE $5.00).

69 Atlantic Ave., Oceanside, L.I., NY 11572

Find out more by calling 516-678-3535 or visiting deesnursery.com/

The Milk Pail

The Milk Pail combines all sorts of fall fun into one great experience. Head over for over 55 varieties of you-pick pumpkins and gourds. While you’re there, enjoy their marketplace offering a variety of fruits, berries, veggies, nuts, herbs, flowers, and treats like pies, brownies, chocolate, cakes, muffins, maple syrup, and more. They even have live entertainment. 

U-Pick Farm Hours:


Regular Hours: Friday, Saturday, & Sunday from 10:00 AM – 5:30 PM

1346 Montauk Hwy., Water Mill, L.I., NY 11976

Find out more by calling 631-537-2565 or visiting milk-pail.com/

Waterdrinker Family Farm & Garden Center

While fall spells extra fun at Waterdrinker, they offer year-round gardening help for both avid and hobby gardeners. When fall rolls around, head over for you-pick pumpkins and stop by their farm stand for roasted corn, pies, fresh lemonade, and fall plants. You’ll also find a corn maze, tractor pedal cars, barnyard animals, mini-golf, an obstacle course, weekend hayrides, and their daily Fall Festival held through October. 

Come to Waterdrinker Family Farm for the pumpkins, corn maze, hayrides, and roasted corn. Stay at the farm for the super useful gardening help. This farm is open daily from 10 – 5p and is much more than just a pumpkin patch. Try your hand at the haunted corn maze one night…if you dare! The pumpkin picking patch is free to enter but if you want to participate in some of the other activities, there is a per person fee of $10/p weekdays and $15/p on weekends.

Hours: 9 AM – 5 PM daily and until sunset on Saturdays. 

663 Wading River Rd., Manorville, L.I., NY 11949

Find out more by calling 631-878-8653 or visiting water-drinker.com/

Source: White Post Farms

White Post Farms

If you can’t find fall fun for the family at White Post, you can’t find it anywhere. In addition to its large, you-pick pumpkin patch, White Post offers a huge variety of family activities. Enjoy your favorites such as Sing-A-Long Hayrides, Pumpkin Picking, and Paint Your Own Pumpkins. Also enjoy five great shows including The Dominguez Poodles, The Pompeyo Dog Show, The Agri-Puppets, Kids Celebration Game Show, and the Magic of Jim McClenahan. Between the activities stop by one of the Fall Food stands for a delicious lunch. Many a birthday party was hosted and attended here as well!

Fall festival tickets are $32.95.

Hours: September 18, 19, 25, 26, Oct. 2, 3 from 10 AM – 4 PM and until 6 PM on weekends & Columbus Day. Oct. 9, 10, 11, 16, 17, 23, 24 from 9 AM – 4 PM and until 6 PM on weekends.

250 Old Country Rd., Melville, L.I., NY 11747

Find out more by calling 631-351-9373 or visiting whitepostfarms.com

Whickham’s Fruit Farm

Offering the simple joys of fall, Whickham’s features you-pick pumpkins and apples along with a farm stand featuring fresh fruits, cheeses, pies, preserves, baked goods, and more. They also have a picnic area for enjoying a crisp fall day. This is a literal, historic institution farmed for almost 300 years. I mean, they have a cider press that was built in 1902!

Hours: 9 AM – 5 PM Monday – Saturday. Closed Sunday. Pick your own apples open Monday to Saturday from 10 AM – 3 PM.

28700 Rt. 25, Cutchogue, L.I., NY 11935

Find out more by calling 631-734-6441 or visiting wickhamsfruitfarm.com/

Windy Acres Farm 

From mini-pumpkins to jumbo varieties, you’ll have plenty to choose from at Windy Acres Farm’s you-pick pumpkin patch. You’ll also be able to pick your own veggies like eggplant, tomatoes, and peppers, and fruits such as peaches, apples, and nectarines, as well as a variety of berries. While you’re there, visit their farm stand for fresh fruits and vegetables, honey, and more. You’ll also find seasonal favorites like gourds, straw bales, cornstalks, candy apples, and mums. Enjoy the new concession stand offering roasted corn, soup, popcorn, kettle corn, cotton candy, and more.

Hours: Open Daily 9 AM – 6 PM, Saturday, Sept. 25th thru Oct. 31st.

3810 Middle Country Rd., Calverton, L.I., NY 11933

Find out more by calling 631-727-4554 or visiting facebook.com/Windy-Acres-Farm-145017335593755/

Woodside Nursery and Garden Center

At Woodside, you’ll find pumpkins ranging from small to large, along with a haunted tunnel, balloon bounce houses, gold mining, scarecrow making, face painting, a balloon artist, and a market featuring a variety of fall plants. 

Hours: 9 AM – 6 PM daily. 

134 E Woodside Ave., North Patchogue, L.I., NY 11722

Find out more by calling 631-758-1491 or visit woodsidenurseryandgarden.com/

Get pumpkin picking Long Island!

These pumpkin picking Long Island farms are open and taking all precautions to keep visitors safe. Halloween doesn’t have to be canceled in 2020. It just might look different. Make a plan to check out one of these pumpkin farms Long Island offers. I’m sure you won’t be disappointed! Don’t forget about Halloween fun including haunted houses, corn mazes, and apple picking, too!

More From The Long Island Local

Maybe grab a freshly brewed beer at these Long Island breweries!

And how about all the wonderful Wölffer Estate Vineyard events and tastings?! Or maybe check out some Long Island oyster farms! How about these guides to Long Island Coffee Shops and Long Island coffee roasters!! Check out these 16 Long Island Boardwalks! Take the ferry over and enjoy these Fire Island restaurants! Let’s not forget about the best tacos on Long Island and these 32 great Long Island pizza places either!! Here are 21 great spots to enjoy Long Island Gelato!

Be sure to find out about more things to do on Long Island as well as more great spots to eat and drink! Maybe take a stroll in one of these amazing Long Island arboretums and gardens! There are even this great Long Island kayaks and paddleboard guide to exploring!

Long Island Farm Guides To Explore

Suffolk County agriculture includes over 560 farms with 4,600 people that generate more than $226 million in sales annually. Long Island knows farming as well as Long Island farmland preservation!! How about enjoying some wonderful Long Island hiking trails!

Check out more Long Island Farm coverage on The Long Island Local!

Explore our Guide to organic farms on Long Island and our Guide to CSA on Long Island.

Read about great events like the Tulip Festival at Waterdrinker Farm and all that the Golden Earthworm has to offer!

What about this massive list of Long Island farmers and farms you need to visit!

How about Long Island Oyster Farms, the last Long Island Duck farm, or the only fresh American snail farm Peconic Escargot!

When the season’s right, explore our Long Island Christmas Tree farm guide and our list of great Long Island pumpkin picking farms!

Check Out Long Island Wine

If you’re in the mood for great wine, be sure to check out our Complete List of Long Island Wineries and Long Island Vineyards.

Check out the absolute best Long Island Wine Tours!

If you can’t make it to a tour, why not do some wine tasting at home with Bedell Cellars!

I know you’re getting hungry, so be sure to also check out the best wineries on Long Island for some great food!

While you’re in the area, be sure to check out these 9 relaxing things to do in the North Fork!

When you’re done with all of this wine drinking and relaxing, how about making it a weekend? Here are 10 great North Fork Long Island hotels to enjoy as well.

Things To See and Do on the South Fork

I always recommend seeing as much of the South Fork as possible!! 

The Hamptons and Montauk is a world-renowned beach resort destination for good reason! There is just so much to see, do, and enjoy! Here are just a few of them:

Check out this Guide to the Best Beaches in Montauk! Also, check out this Guide to The Hamptons best beaches!!

Check out some luxury homes in The Hamptons!

Maybe you will love it so much, you’ll want to check out some Hamptons wedding venues!

Enjoy some of the world-class, amazing art in The Hamptons!

While You’re Enjoying the Outdoors

Be sure to find out about more things to do on Long Island as well as more great spots to eat and drink and wonderful places to stay on Long Island!

Check out this guide to Long Island driving ranges, including this feature on the popular Heartland driving range! Go have fun at one of these great Long Island skate parks!

Make It A Weekend

The East End of Long Island is a really special spot. If you think you’d want to check it out and maybe even stay a while…that wouldn’t be such a terrible idea.

If you wanted to consider different options for staying on Long Island, be sure to check out these great places to stay in Montauk, 11 Hamptons hotels, 10 North Fork Long Island hotels, and this Guide to Sag Harbor hotels! Enjoy reading up on and hopefully exploring these wonderful Shelter Island hotels and let me know if you decide to make it a vacation!

Share This!

Related Articles

Leave a Comment

This website uses third party applications that may use cookies to improve your experience. You can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More

Privacy & Cookies Policy